Thats why I kept voting as OPEN, in otherwords, voting won't close for three days even if there is a majority. That should give some people to play, consider, change your mind.
It is much more difficult to do due dilligence in the middle of the season. Everyone has only three days to play three games of their own series, and then try to play the new guy as well and make a logical assumption as to how he's going to play over the course of one month in that one game.
He has nyy as a reference. He seems eager to play. I'd much rather have a live player than a series of coin flips decide these games, especially on a team smack in the middle of the race.
You (and everyone else in the Founders Club) has the right to vote differently.